Locally owned only
Food & Drink in Niagara Falls, NY
Where locals actually eat and drink in Niagara Falls, Lewiston, Youngstown, the Town of Niagara and Wheatfield. Our picks first, then every independent spot from A to Z.
⭐ Our Picks
⭐ Best Overall
- 1 Red Coach Inn Restaurant Order this: Start with the baked spinach and artichoke dip and the French onion au gratin. For dinner, get the Chicken French (egg-dipped chicken breast in a sherry lemon butter sauce with creamy parmesan risotto) or the homemade meatloaf with mushroom demi-glace and sour cream chive smashed potatoes. In summer, eat it on the patio with the mist coming off the river.
- 2 Mister M's House of Food & Drink Order this: The "Baddest Beef on Weck in Town," slow-roasted and piled high on a kummelweck roll. The Stinger sub is one of the best around, and the steak & cheese pizza on cauliflower crust is famous. Really hungry? The Buffalo Boss Combo gets you a beef on weck plus 5 wings.
🍸 Best Cocktails
🍳 Best Breakfast & Brunch
🧁 Best Bakery & Desserts
- 1 The Village Bake Shoppe Order this: The cupcakes, homemade fresh every day. Get the banana, red velvet or German chocolate. Grab one (or a box) after a walk along the Lewiston waterfront.
- 2 DiCamillo Bakery Order this: The homemade donuts and bread, made fresh every day. Grab a hand-rolled loaf of Scaletta bread (their most-requested item) and a Peanut Stik donut. Take home biscotti or sponge candy.
🐟 Best Friday Fish Fry
- 1 Gadawski's Restaurant Order this: The Friday fish fry. And don't leave without trying the pierogi.
- 2 The Griffon Gastropub, Military Road Order this: The chicken fingers, hand-made and hand-dipped in their special batter. On Fridays, the fish fry with Cajun Crunch batter.
- 3 Taylor's Tap & Grill Order this: The homemade Pizza Trunks (their pizza logs), made fresh every day and each about the size of a small burrito. Get the classic pepperoni & cheese or the steak & cheese. On Fridays, the fish fry is outstanding.
🕯️ Best Date Night
☀️ Best Patio
- 1 The Griffon Gastropub, Lewiston Order this: The chicken fingers, hand-made and hand-dipped in their special batter. On Fridays, the Cajun Crunch fish fry. In summer, come for a band and stay for dinner.
- 2 Red Coach Inn Restaurant Order this: Start with the baked spinach and artichoke dip and the French onion au gratin. For dinner, get the Chicken French (egg-dipped chicken breast in a sherry lemon butter sauce with creamy parmesan risotto) or the homemade meatloaf with mushroom demi-glace and sour cream chive smashed potatoes. In summer, eat it on the patio with the mist coming off the river.
🌙 Best Late Night
Every local spot, A–Z
D
- DiCamillo Bakery The homemade donuts and bread, made fresh every day. Grab a hand-rolled loaf of Scaletta bread (their most-requested item) and a Peanut Stik donut. Take home biscotti or sponge candy.
- DiCamillo Bakery, Lewiston The homemade donuts and bread, made fresh every day. Grab a hand-rolled loaf of Scaletta bread (their most-requested item) and a Peanut Stik donut. Take home biscotti or sponge candy.
- Duff's Famous Wings The classic hot wings, made with Frank's. Grab an ice-cold fountain loganberry to go with them.
G
- Gadawski's Restaurant The Friday fish fry. And don't leave without trying the pierogi.
- The Griffon Gastropub, Lewiston The chicken fingers, hand-made and hand-dipped in their special batter. On Fridays, the Cajun Crunch fish fry. In summer, come for a band and stay for dinner.
- The Griffon Gastropub, Military Road The chicken fingers, hand-made and hand-dipped in their special batter. On Fridays, the fish fry with Cajun Crunch batter.
L
M
- Mister M's House of Food & Drink The "Baddest Beef on Weck in Town," slow-roasted and piled high on a kummelweck roll. The Stinger sub is one of the best around, and the steak & cheese pizza on cauliflower crust is famous. Really hungry? The Buffalo Boss Combo gets you a beef on weck plus 5 wings.
- Mr. Ventry's Pizza on the Boulevard The classic cheese & pepperoni half-tray pizza.